Reviews on metahub are written by the people who use these artifacts. This page explains how they work, what we show, and the only grounds on which we remove anything, so you know exactly what to expect.
Anyone can leave a review. Sign in with GitHub and your review carries a “verified” badge; post as a guest and it appears unverified. Reviews are published right away and rated from one to five stars. Publishers can post a single public response to a review.
We do not edit reviews, reorder them, or remove them based on their rating or sentiment. A one-star review is treated exactly the same as a five-star one. We never write reviews ourselves, never pay for them, and never suppress honest criticism.
A review may be held for moderation or removed only when it contains:
These are neutral, consistently applied grounds, never the star rating. Moderation actions are logged.
If a published review contains personal information about you, ask us to remove it using the report control on the review, or contact us; we’ll take it down.
Every review has a report control. Flagged reviews go to a moderator, who decides whether to keep or remove them on the grounds above. Reporting a review you simply disagree with won’t get it removed.
Questions about a review or a removal request? Use the report control on the review, or the Feedback button in the corner of any page.